The Slater Case (12 october 1912)
From The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia
The Slater Case
[To The Editor of the "Spectator."]
Sir, — Mr. Risk's long letter upon this subject is full of inaccuracies. His idea of argument seems to be simply to make assertions of things which were never proved at the trial, and thus to form a post-factum justification of the verdict. His allegation that certain gamblers knew of the existence of Miss Gilchrist's jewels was never even alluded to at the trial, and the police entirely failed to prove that Slater travelled to Liverpool with anything but a Liverpool ticket. As he had previously announced to several people where he was going, it seems highly improbable that he bought a London ticket in order to throw pursuit off his track. As to the assertion that Slater confessed, I am entirely incredulous upon the subject. Slater's words (reported in several forms) seem to me to bear the interpretation that if he were executed it would be the death of his mistress also. The so-called confession was entirely denied by Mr. Spiers, Slater's solicitor, who, not only in public but in the privacy of his own family, asserted his belief in the complete innocence of his client up to the day of his death. Slater also protested his innocence after reaching prison, which is surely incompatible with the idea that he had already made a confession of guilt.
Mr. Risk's logic and temper may be judged by the sentence, " Even if Slater were innocent, ... Peterhead" (meaning penal servitude) "is the proper place for him." Of course, if that is so there is an end of the discussion. But some of us still retain an old-fashioned prejudice in favour of a man being punished for the crime that he is tried for, and not for the morals of his private life. — I am, Sir, &c.,
Arthur Conan Doyle.
Windlesham, Crowborough, Sussex.
- The Case of Oscar Slater (19 august 1912, Hodder & Stoughton Ltd.)
- The Case of Oscar Slater (2 september 1912, Daily Mail)
- The Case of Oscar Slater (13 october 1912, The New York World)
- The Slater Case (26 october 1912, The Spectator)
- The Oscar Slater Case (25 july 1914, The Spectator)
- Oscar Slater Must Be Release From Peterhead! (7 february 1925, People's Journal)
- Oscar Slater. Release from Prison this Week. The Farce of 1914 (14 november 1927, Daily News)
- Oscar Slater's Fight to Clear his Name (15 july 1928, Sunday Pictorial)
- Oscar Slater. My Last Words on the Case. Unsolved Mysteries (29 july 1928, The Sunday Times)
- The Oscar Slater Case (17 september 1928, The Times)
- Oscar Slater's Costs (19 april 1929, Jewish Chronicle)